Cesspool concerns shutter Camp Hale Koa

  • Sabrina Bodon / The Garden Island

    The Rev. Rick Bundschuh, executive director of the nonprofit Camp Hale Koa Association and pastor of the Kaua‘i Christian Fellowship in Po‘ipu, stands at the camp in Waimea Canyon State Park.

  • Sabrina Bodon / The Garden Island

    The Rev. Rick Bundschuh, executive director of the nonprofit Camp Hale Koa Association and pastor of the Kaua‘i Christian Fellowship in Po‘ipu, tries to open a closed bathroom on the camp’s property in Waimea Canyon State Park.

  • Sabrina Bodon / The Garden Island

    At left is the filled-in cesspool at Camp Hale Koa in Waimea Canyon State Park.

KOKE‘E — After a decade of rehabilitating and leasing a four-acre campsite, the Camp Hale Koa Association is in limbo.

The camp located in Waimea Canyon State Park has been shuttered since October 2019, shut down due to the illegal operation of a state-owned, large-capacity cesspool, which the Camp Hale Koa Association had no knowledge needed to be converted.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency required the closure and replacement of existing large-capacity cesspools in 2005, under the Safe Drinking Water Act.

During a walk-through of the property in 2019, the EPA flagged the cesspools, said the Rev. Rick Bundschuh, executive director of the nonprofit Camp Hale Koa Association and pastor of Kaua’i Christian Fellowship in Po‘ipu. That year, the state Department of Land and Natural Resources, from which CHKA is leasing the property, shut down the camp.

Bundschuh said the camp was not informed of the existence of the cesspool nor conversions prior to taking a 10-year lease from DLNR in 2015. Had they known about the cesspool and potential fines, Bundschuh said CHKA might not have taken the property on in the first place over a decade ago in 2011 under a year-to-year, revocable lease.

Cesspools, which collect raw, untreated sewage, are the primary method for disposal of sewage within Waimea Canyon and Koke‘e state parks.

There are cesspools on all leased cabin lots, according to a 2015 report from DLNR, including at the NASA facility and the Air Force facility. Private systems have been developed at other camping sites, according to the DLNR report.

For Camp Hale Koa, the cost would be around $300,000 to install a new septic system.

The exact amount of fines that the state could be facing is unclear. The EPA does not comment on pending litigation, and DLNR did not respond to questions posed.

Hearing that the camp was closed, a donor came forward to CHKA, offering to pay for the work, but it’s conditioned on the state extending CHKA’s lease. The nonprofit has not had any correspondence from DLNR since September 2020.

Keeping Camp Hale Koa affordable

Over the years, with the help of community members, Camp Hale Koa Association has turned the abandoned set of eight cabins, main hall, kitchen and caretaker cabin into an affordable camping experience for locals.

Bundschuh had been coming to the camp since 1984. He guesses it may have been kept as a medical barracks at one time, as evidenced by medicine bottles found on the site.

It cost about $30,000 to refurbish and furnish each cabins, much of the materials to restore the camp forming from grants and gifts.

“We had crews of local volunteers, weekends after weekends. I don’t know that you could count the hours,” CHKA board member Sarah Hill said. “A lot of locals in the community came and invested their time here.”

Hill has been running student ministries on the North Shore for over 18 years, often bringing kids of all ages to assist in the renovations.

“I’d bring troves of students up on the weekend,” Hill said. “They’d get to cleaning up the property, picking up trash, painting cabins and working on the main hall.”

The privacy and seclusion of the site without the internet allow for deeper, personal connections without distractions, Hill said.

“Some of the kids return to crazy atmospheres, so we encourage them to hold tight the things that they got up here,” Hill said. “It’s like they’re taken out of the comfort zones of this world and put into a place where they have to admire and enjoy the wilderness. They just get real. It’s really amazing, heavy talks.”

Part of CHKA’s goal is to make that experience affordable, Bundschuh said. Average rates are about $420 a night for any group of under 35. That’s about $12 per camper, with a 35-person minimum.

“We don’t want it to be turned into something that just weeds out the local people,” Hill said.

Adding portable toilets to the facilities in lieu of a septic system would cost about $650, which on top of a weekend night at the camp, a weekend would be about $1,000, Bundschuh said.

CHKA submits options to DLNR

Camp Hale Koa Association was initially given a year-to-year, revocable permit lease prior to a 10-year lease that was signed in 2015 for the 4.06 acres of land, with an annual rent of $480.

In supporting documents for the application, DLNR acknowledges CHKA’s work done to the property.

“Staff has visited the toured the camp and confirm the association has done a good job in restoring the camp as well as to provide the community with an affordable group-camping environment which services their targeted groups of religious, youth and families,” the April 24, 2015 application states.

CHKA recently extended two options for DLNR regarding the current situation.

The first option suggests that DLNR pay to install the septic tank and allow the camp to have a new, 10-year lease at $5,000 per year as a way to help the state pay for the cost. This 10-year lease would start once the current lease has expired.

The second option would require CHKA to borrow $300,000 to pay for the septic system, but requests the state enter into a 30-year lease at $1,000 a year so that the association could make monthly payments on the loan.

“With a 30-year lease, I am very confident that we will find the funds,” said Joe McEvoy, CKHA treasurer, in a letter. “My goal is to receive grant money to cover 50% of the cost and borrow the balance on a 30-year loan,” he said.

“I personally would use my home as collateral if needed because I believe in what Camp Hale Koa is trying to do for Kaua‘i in making affordable lodging available to everyone.”

Having a long-term lease with the state would allow the group to recoup the money and fulfill its mission, Bundschuh said.

Kaua‘i state Rep. Dee Morikawa wrote to the DLNR about a year after the closure, in September 2020.

“CHK had no knowledge of the state’s pre-existing violation of the EPA’s LCC (large-capacity cesspool) regulations. There were no verbal communications or written documents, the lease included, that notified CHK of probable EPA fines and the closure of the LCC. The state was not in compliance with EPA regulations at the time of the lease and the lease did not transfer the state’s burden to CHK,” Morikawa wrote.

This month, Morikawa recognized the position both the camp and the state are in, facing tight finances in the wake of the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.

“Our economy is in bad shape, and usage of the facility will be drastically low in the future,” Morikawa said. “I hope that the department will work with Camp Hale Koa to come to some agreement to the conversion of the cesspool to a septic system because it will be very difficult for the state to do the conversions themselves.”

All the cesspools on the property were filled-in by the end of last year by DLNR, Bundschuh said.

Hearing crickets from DLNR has been disheartening for CHKA, with the camp continuing to look for answers, he said.

“If they would have disclosed (the fines) to us, then we would have known what we were getting into,” Bundschuh said.

This story was updated Monday, Jan. 25 to provide clarity.

8 Comments
  1. MisterM January 24, 2021 5:56 am Reply

    Bad idea to let religious nutters near kids, especially at camps away from their parents. Parents, wake up!


  2. Hirondelle January 24, 2021 7:14 am Reply

    This is the canary in the coal mines for Kauai and the rest of the islands. That so-called “early warning” confirms what is already known: Hawaii needs better sewage treatment and disposal. Funds must be dedicated to switching from cesspools and inadequate grandfathered in multifamily septics to updated systems. No lot or resort should be developed unless the owner commits to infrastructure that includes sewage treatment and disposal; and that should be put in place before a wall is erected. Effluence does, indeed, flow downhill. Public and private funding should flow to correcting the problem, not adding to it with further development.


  3. Rev Dr Malama January 24, 2021 8:17 am Reply

    Making exceptions or exemptions for one group is just plain wrong.
    The federal mandate is for every single illegal cesspool to be replaced or the business and individuals must leave….
    Returning to an equitable government under God is the 1st step to Retribution and Reconciliation towards our local people.
    Anything less is just corruption and lies.
    We stand together at
    HAWAIIANKINGDOM.ORG


  4. Rick bundschuh January 24, 2021 1:12 pm Reply

    I appreciate the Garden Island telling our story. A couple of point for clarity and accuracy – we knew that the camp used cesspools for wastewater…what we did not know, nor were informed of when we leased the camp was that the DLNR knew they were now illegal and that they were liable for a fine as they should have been converted six years previous to our getting the lease. (Then when we expressed dismay at this fact the DLNR told us that it was our problem and we should have done due diligence and found out for ourselves.) Also for clarity – the cost for refurbishing each of the eight cabins was around 30k each.


  5. Rick Bundschuh January 24, 2021 1:33 pm Reply

    Point of accuracy – the DLNR, not CHKA paid for the backfilling of the cesspools.


  6. Rick Bundschuh January 25, 2021 6:53 am Reply

    Thank you Garden Island for publishing this story. A couple of points for accuracy: CHKA was aware that the camp had cesspools but we were not aware that they were illegal. Also the cost to refurbish cabins was 30k (with bunks etc.) per cabin and finally the DLNR not CHKA paid for the backfilling of the cesspools.


  7. Kauaidoug January 25, 2021 1:35 pm Reply

    Sounds like someone should have known they were leasing property that was in serious environmental non compliance. The camp is needed for our youth and should have the island’s full support, especially post covid. Maybe a letter from a lawyer would get a response from DLNR?


  8. Mona January 25, 2021 7:24 pm Reply

    So thankful to have Kaua’i Christian Fellowship to share this camp to encourage and support our Youth and families. In this day of high technology seems there should be some affordable septic options.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.