DLNR draws lawsuit

LIHUE — The State’s Department of Land and Natural Resources is drawing a lawsuit from the environmental law firm Earthjustice, claiming the agency has created loopholes for the aquarium fishing industry to continue unregulated.

The coalition Earthjustice is representing has been threatening for weeks to file suit against DLNR because the entity has continued to issue permits for aquarium collection after a 2017 Hawaii Supreme Court ruling that required the industry to include environmental review before aquarium fishing is allowed.

And while the coalition points out DLNR problems with handing out permits for the activity, DLNR says they’re following the rule as they interpret it.

“Under current law, commercial aquarium fishing is allowed as long as collectors have a valid commercial marine license and are using legal gear and methods. This is applicable for all areas except West Hawaii, where all aquarium collection is prohibited until an environmental review is completed,” DLNR said in a statement to TGI on Monday.

Staff members acknowledged it’s the same statement they’ve been providing the public for more than a year —in the media and at public meetings, some of which included members of the coalition filing suit against the entity.

DLNR’s Dan Dennison said the entity couldn’t comment further on the lawsuit on Monday, because they hadn’t yet seen it.

“We respect Earthjustice’s right to pursue this matter in court if it believes that is the right thing to do. We have not seen the lawsuit and cannot comment on its substance,” Dennison said.

The lawsuit comes weeks after a January 7 letter from the coalition represented by Earthjustice, asking for a meeting to discuss current policies for permit issuance.

Earthjustice says they never got a response to that letter and that DLNR did not “take any actions to correct course.”

The topic boiled into the public arena with the 2017 Hawaii Supreme Court ruling that commercial aquarium collection under permits is subject to environmental review under the Hawai‘i Environmental Policy Act. After that ruling, the Circuit Court voided all permits and ordered a moratorium on renewing or issuing new aquarium collection permits pending the environmental review process.

DLNR continues to issue commercial permits, because they interpret the ruling as banning the use of fine-meshed gear, which they no longer allow to be used.

The coalition represented by Earthjustice is made up of conservation groups and Native Hawaiians, including Mike Nakachi, a Native Hawaiian cultural practitioner.

“Hawai‘i’s reefs are the lifeblood of Kanaka Maoli and our communities,” Nakachi said. “We simply can’t afford to allow the aquarium trade to continue lawlessly, putting private profits over the health and protection of our public trust resources.”

  1. tunataxi January 28, 2020 11:16 am Reply

    First tropical fish collecting… Then spearfishing…. Net fishing… Line fishing. Mark my words these people wonʻt be happy until we are all eating tofu.

  2. Debra Kekaualua January 28, 2020 2:47 pm Reply

    DLNR has a long history of resource mismanagment of Hawaii resources. In this case aquarium. However, the awesome nature of Earthjustice has also had water related judiciary court hearings and in that case, here on Kaua’i, no one seems to have heard like I did with an MP from PMRF who was coming off duty watching the PMRF water well that “only” the military gets to use, while our COK DOW sends out post cards to residents advising them to purchase their drinking water! Now, while I agree totally with this lawsuit by earth justice for aquarium issues, water is life and without it, humanity does not survive! So, Earth Justice, I plead with your amazing “feet on the ground” to terminate “aquarium” and find out what or why military over residents is the name of the current games which include more than a Billion dollars for Kauai ballistic missile activities and upgrades by 2022 that Obama and Biden was said in the impeachment hearing yesterday newscast to have stoked their vision to make Hawaii ground zero, when the last Oops came out from Vandenberg AFB, California and was intercepted by PMRF, not an ooops, a bonified coverup, just like the recent tour helicopter incident! USA would have blamed NK had oops landed in hawaii-nei. People are being duped while Obama, not an american citizen, born in the Hawaiian Islands that has never been and will never be america! We are still alive and well. We tell truth, not lies that confused the world. The U.N. now has corrected information and U.S.A. is in game Over mode!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.