Council votes ‘no’ to pension overtime cap

LIHUE — A bill that would have placed a cap on the amount of overtime considered to be “compensation” for pension retirement benefits, won’t be included in the 2020 Hawaii State Association of Counties Legislative Package.

The bill aimed to improve the short-term viability and long-term outlook for the Employees’ Retirement System of the State of Hawaii by combating what is referred to as “pension spiking.” It’s when employees allegedly boost their pay intentionally through avenues, such as overtime, during their final three years of work in order to inflate their pension benefits.

Councilmembers decided that the bill for an act was too wide of a net to cast for a small number of people taking advantage of the system. Councilmember Kipukai Kuali‘i said that he would like to correct the abuse but wants to be careful that others aren’t punished for it in the meantime.

He also added that “some of the abuses” are specifically coming from the fire department and that there is an audit currently happening that is focusing on “spiking” within the county.

Councilmembers agreed that it’s an issue that still needs to be addressed because the county is going to have to fill a “looming” $8 million puka in the next few years because of it, Council Vice Chair Ross Kagawa said.

The money will have to come from somewhere and since “un-funding” the county’s annual budget is “unrealistic,” the only way it will be paid is by increasing citizen’s taxes, he said.

Therefore, other options will have to be considered. Otherwise, Kagawa said it will end up costing upcoming generations, especially “children who don’t have a job yet.”

The county’s excess pension costs due to seven “spiking” retirees during the fiscal year 2014 was around $213,000. That number was approximately ten times higher four years later when 21 spiking retirees cost some $2.4 million.

“We’re not taking away the benefit, we’re changing the benefit,” said Councilmember Mason Chock regarding the purpose of his proposed legislation, adding that he hoped the issue would continue to be discussed, particularly at the state level.

Unions like the Hawaii Government Employees Association (HGEA) weren’t supportive of the legislation for a variety of reasons. One is that there isn’t evidence that employees are doing anything wrong, according to Caroline Sluyter, communications officer for the HGEA. When The Garden Island reached out to her on Wednesday regarding the county council’s vote, she declined to comment.

Kagawa said he isn’t afraid to keep kicking the can down the road.

“Because it’s a problem that needs to be fixed,” he said. “I’m trying to speak for all the people who don’t work for the government.”


Coco Zickos, county reporter, can be reached at 245-0424 or

  1. Knowitall September 12, 2019 3:38 am Reply

    Pension spiking isn’t even a secret in various county jobs with a high 3 or high 5 retirement

  2. rk669 September 12, 2019 5:55 am Reply

    Pension Spiking? Is this Practice,Considered Theft?

  3. Jared Young September 12, 2019 8:10 am Reply

    So, all bark and no bite. Zip, zero. The past mayor went 10 years without even a dent in this issue. The council had another, fresh opportunity to do something and it ended up just ‘discussing’ the issue. God forbid we actually fix it because that would likely mean a few lost union votes. Pathetic.

  4. LMat September 12, 2019 8:38 am Reply

    Keep kicking that can Ross. This isn’t something that you guys can keep deferring. The bill was a good idea and lots of us are glad that you brought it forward.
    If the community isn’t angry about having to, in essence, pay for these guys’s retirement, idk what to say… It’s greed and selfishness and everybody should be angry about it, I don’t care how prominent or “respected” or liked these retirees are. These guys should be SHAME.

  5. Rev Dr. Malama September 12, 2019 9:17 am Reply

    OMG help us all! “NO EVIDENCE OF ANY WRONGDOING ” but…
    Council member Felicia voted for infringement of Fire Fighters and other civil servant’s cap on retirement pension…. against her “very uncomfortable ” in doing so.
    Let’s put these pressure on the politicians to prove why we should be paying them!!!

  6. Joe Public September 12, 2019 10:00 am Reply

    Check the CBA, it is based on base pay now, not high 3

  7. Justmyopinion September 12, 2019 1:50 pm Reply

    Mr Chock, and others. Pension spiking IS NOT A BENEFIT. It is a LOOP HOLE due to improper and inadequate wording in the state pension documents. It must be corrected and the “loop hole” closed.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.