‘Pay-per-mile’ proposal doesn’t add up

Having read the recent article on the proposal to change from a state tax on gas and diesel fuel, to a pay-per-mile charge, I decided to look into the actual numbers being used to justify the change, and to see who the winners and losers would be.

The reading may be boring, but the results may surprise you. If you are not into lots of boring numbers, jump to number 5.

1. From 2017 to 2018 there was actually a small increase in state taxes collected on gasoline and diesel fuel for highway use. But, that is not the only source of fuel taxes. Aviation fuel taxes went up, and the largest decrease was in taxes on gasoline and diesel for boats, and diesel fuel used for off-road use (construction equipment, farm equipment, etc.)

Overall, the state collected $194,761,230 in total fuel taxes in 2017 and $201,772,728 in 2018, an increase of $7,011,498.

However, from 2016 to 2017 there was a drop in revenue, but it rebounded in 2018 by 3.6 million over 2016 levels.

So, the justification for changing the system being “the loss of fuel-tax revenue due to higher fuel efficiencies and the growing use of electric vehicles” really does not hold much water.

State Rep. Sylvia Luke recently stated in an article in Hawaii News Now that the tax revenues have been dwindling by $30 million, but the state’s own numbers tell a different story.

State tax revenues from gas and diesel for 2017 were $ 82,004,997, and in 2018 $ 82,336,357, an increase of $331,360. This is far from the stated $30 million being lost.

2. They have stated that the proposal will be “revenue-neutral.” If they are trying to raise more money, why would they even say that? To make it seem like it is not going to cost you anything. But, let’s assume that it is in fact revenue-neutral.

So how are they going to figure out how many miles you actually drive? Three other states have tested this on a limited basis. One way is to install a chip that tracks you via GPS. The cost of such a system would be extreme, and there are certainly privacy issues. The second way is via the mileage recorded year to year on your inspection certificate. As it turns out, the state already tracks that.

3. According to the state in 2017 (the latest data I could get), statewide, the average driver used 478 gallons of gas and diesel and drove 9,415 miles. Overall, we drove 1,135,060,000 miles (yes, that is 1.1 billion miles).

On Kauai we drove a total of 886,000,000 miles (yup, 886 million), used on average 568 gallon of gas and diesel, and averaged 10,322 miles each.

4. So, how do they figure out what to charge per mile? The most logical would be to take the tax revenues on gas and diesel ($82,004,997) and divide by total miles driven, to come up with 7.2 cents per mile. If they did that, the numbers would be staggering! As of today, the proposals have been vague, with no real data or numbers that I can find. So, I may be way off base with the per-mile charge they are proposing.

But even at 2 cents a mile, it will take extra money out or your pocket. California is proposing a 5-cents-per-mile charge.

5. So, how will this effect you, assuming the 7.2 cents a mile? Using the state averages for Kauai, if you drove 10,322 miles and drove a pickup that gets 16 miles per gallon, you used 645 gallons of gas and paid $103.22 in taxes. If you paid by the mile, it will cost you $743.18, or $ 639.96 more a year.

If you drive, say, a Ford Escape (I do) that gets 25 miles to a gallon, you bought 413 gallons of gas and paid $66.06 in gas taxes. So, it will cost me $677.12 more. If you drive an electric vehicle, it will cost you $743.18 more a year, since you pay no gas taxes now.

Now, even at 2 cents a mile, that 10,322 miles would cost $206.44, much more than you are paying in gas taxes now.

The real issue is that when you pay the gas tax, it is in small amounts, say 3 or 4 dollars a fill up. This levy will most likely be added to your yearly registration fee, so your $350 registration could now be a $1,000 registration. Plus, you would still be paying the county tax of 17 cents a gallon when you fill up.

And of course, when they need more money, they simply raise the money-per-mile charge.

For years they have pushed us to buy more-fuel-efficient vehicles or even hybrids or EVs. Any savings by doing so just went down the drain if this proposal passes.

The state is holding a series of informational meetings on this proposal. I highly recommend you attend and press them hard on the actual amount per mile and how often and by how much they will be raising the charge (which they surely will).

And in the end, start saving a few bucks every time you get gas, since the politicians don’t care what you think anyways!

But, when no one can afford to drive, it sure fixes our traffic problems.


Barry Dittler is a Wailua resident.

  1. james March 18, 2019 8:02 am Reply

    Agree, not fair. Don’t we want to encourage environmental responsible behavior, not punish it?

  2. Rev Dr. Malama March 18, 2019 8:19 am Reply

    Yes, it does not take a rocket scientist to see that we have TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION IN HAWAII!!!
    Politicians tell us whatever they want without any credibility so senior, disabled and impoverished people like myself are forced to do without reliable transportation….
    But that is another story!

  3. LiarLiar March 18, 2019 11:18 am Reply

    If state representative Sylvia Luke lies to the public during a public testimony then she should face disciplinary actions or perjury charges.

    If house and senate can charge citizens with lying to them then the public should be able to charge politicians committing the same crime.

    Luke should be held accountable for cooking the books and falsifying information and anyone else should also face public scrutiny.

    The state of Hawaii and it’s counties cannot keep letting those who circumvent the laws and believe that they are untouchables.

    This is what happened in the Kealoha case and all those involved. We have the same investigation going on with the Honolulu Rail.

    Now add this faux mileage tax to the public corruption probe. The people should call for a federal investigation on politicians willing to commit perjury in order to pass public law(s).

    Liar Liar was a funny movie but people who create laws that affect the lives of the general public should not be acting as movie characters

  4. rk669 March 18, 2019 6:30 pm Reply

    We live in a Democrat Tax and Spend State! Who did you Vote For!
    Wise Up!

  5. Z March 19, 2019 11:30 am Reply

    So if you buy a vechile that gets better gas mileage why should we all be punished now for doing so I thought it was suppose to help the effects on global warming . Go after the electric car buyers charge the for miles driven and also tax them for the energy they use to charge there batteries and leave the rest of us alone .the next tax will be on each piece of toilet paper we use and how many times we flush our toilets.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.