Breaking News

Breaking News


Cabbies fight to survive

  • Caleb Loehrer / The Garden Island

    The taxi dispatch phone is at the south end of the Lihue Airport terminal.

LIHUE — Uber and Lyft drivers were allowed to start making pickups at select airports in Hawaii Feb. 1, including Lihue Airport, and taxi drivers on Kauai are feeling the squeeze.

The number of customers who request a taxi after getting off a plane in Lihue has dropped dramatically since the first of the month, according to dispatchers and taxi drivers who estimate they are getting about half the number of calls compared to two weeks ago.

Now, many of those drivers, some of whom have have depended for decades on the fares they get from Lihue Airport, find themselves on the verge of losing their livelihood.

One cab driver, Leonora Carlos, said that if things keep up like this, instead of waiting her turn for a fare, “next time, you know, we lining up at EBT!”

“It’s not profitable,” she said. “We’re losing money.”

Joe Llego, a driver on the island for the last decade, said he noticed the drop off in business immediately after the ride-share companies started operating at the airport. Llego said he recently waited for six hours, only to pick up a customer going into Lihue — a fare worth around $10.

“How you gonna pay gas?” he asked.

Llego and Carlos are not the only taxi drivers operating at a deficit this month. Several drivers told stories about waiting five to seven hours in the taxi parking lot at the airport for customers to request their services.

Andy, a driver who asked that his last name be withheld, said he gave up and went home without collecting a single fare one day last week, after waiting six hours for the taxi dispatch phone to ring.

Caroline Castillo started driving a taxi on Kauai Feb. 1, the first day Uber and Lyft drivers were allowed to make airport pickups.

“And then I wait here seven hours. For me it’s really bad because I wait seven hours, and then I get $15. That’s my one day,” she said. “How I can survive? How I can feed myself?”

Carlos, chimed in, “Not you, what about your two kids?”

When asked if there was any way taxi drivers could avoid going out of business, Carlos said, “Put us at the curb. That’s the solution.”

At Lihue Airport, taxi drivers are required to park in a separate lot away from the terminal and can only pick up customers who call the airport’s dispatch service from a phone near the baggage claim area.

Her sentiment was echoed by a number of other drivers standing around the taxi dispatch kiosk, who feel that airport administrators are enforcing a set of antiquated rules that are inefficient, essentially negating the relative simplicity and accessibility that appeals to those who prefer to take a taxi instead of using Uber or Lyft.

“I want an answer,” said cab driver Steven Carvalho. “Why don’t we have a presence at the terminal?”

Craig Davis, manager of the Lihue Airport for the state Department of Transportation Airports Division, could not be reached for comment. Officials with HDOT said Davis was out of his office and not available to take a phone call.

HDOT Director of Communications Tim Sakahara said last week he doesn’t understand why taxi drivers feel they are at a competitive disadvantage.

“In a lot of ways, the setup favors the taxi drivers,” Sakahara said. “They have a phone on site and a staging area at the airport, which the TNCs (transportation network companies) don’t have.”

According to Sakahara, Uber and Lyft drivers are required to comply with the same regulations and laws that apply to cab companies, but at least one taxi company owner doesn’t believe that is the case.

Greg Disilvestri, owner of 635-Taxi, wrote an email to airport administrators and the Kauai County Council last week, insisting that ride-share companies are given preferential treatment when it comes to making sure their drivers have the proper insurance and background checks required to make airport pickups.

“The airport does not have the individual TNC vehicles’ insurance or driver information. Instead the airport trusts the TNC to make sure that its drivers have supplied the TNC and are in compliance,” Disilvestri wrote.

“Can I/my company, a pre-arranged transportation provider who has provided Lihue Airport with 18 years of service, also be afforded this trust?” Disilvestri asked in his email. “No, I must supply the DOT with a physical certificate of insurance at the airport along with a list of other required documents, medical checks for drivers, etc.”

Disilvestri’s email also said that, contrary to common public perception, ride-share companies are not necessarily cheaper than taxis.

“Taxis are always cheaper than the UberXL (a van) and also cheaper then UberX on many occasions,” he wrote, explaining that because all taxis that operate out of Lihue Airport are vans or SUVs, they offer the equivalent service of UberXL, a more expensive option for customers with a large group or a lot of luggage.

One taxi driver is even trying to organize his fellow cab drivers, hoping to get a substantial number of them to offer their services via TagMyTaxi, a mobile application similar to the platforms used by ride-share companies.

Tusuenee Briggs said Friday that he has the signatures of 10 taxi drivers on Kauai who have agreed to use the app, and he hopes to start using TagMyTaxi on a trial basis under a company he plans to call Alpha Cabs.

“We’re gonna be pretty much the same thing as Uber,” Briggs said.

A spokesperson for Lyft said in an email that the company has received positive feedback from drivers and passengers about the new expanded service at Lihue Airport, and said Lyft executives “look forward to working with local leadership on how we may continue to provide reliable and convenient transportation options for locals and visitors alike.”

Uber representatives did not respond to a request for comment.

•••

Caleb Loehrer, staff writer, can be reached at 245-0441 or cloehrer@thegardenisland.com.

14 Comments
  1. Ted DeMarce February 17, 2019 8:14 am Reply

    This is a sad tale,,, I will only use a taxi driver, why? its not the money, its the drivers. They are happy to see you, tell you things about what’s going on. They tell you where new places to eat are, places to go.. They are just like good neighbors from home. They are also very honest people, we need to give them more business. Yes when we come to the islands we have a rental car. I like a little wine with dinner and love to be taken to dinner and brought home safe. Thanks you Cab drivers…. Ted & Mary – Wenatchee Wa.


  2. Uncleaina February 17, 2019 9:27 am Reply

    Times have changed. The old massive rip-off taxi fares are pau. Uber is about 1/2 the price of a taxi. Just like if you owned a grocery store you didn’t want Costco. The fact is DOT *prevented* Uber from going to the airport here on Kauai for at least a year to help these guys out. They can’t act like they didn’t know this was happening. Mainland airports have had Uber for years.


    1. Rio silver February 18, 2019 2:15 pm Reply

      You are wrong. Kauai taxis are cheaper than the equivalent service the” ride share companies “ offer. And just the term ride share sums it up as fraud, nobody is sharing a ride


  3. John Zwiebel February 17, 2019 10:57 am Reply

    Perhaps the county can figure out a way of “persuading” Uber and Lyft to include Taxi’s on their apps. I realize that the ride-share companies will not be happy with this suggestion. However even though it has been out for for a year, “Tagmytaxi” doesn’t have enough ratings on the App store to give it a rating so it isn’t clear that it would be used by customers who already have Uber and Lyft on their phone.

    All drivers should be aware that Uber is going to have self-driving cars soon so plan ahead. There isn’t a good solution for this problem, but like global warming, it is happening and we need to prepare for it.


    1. Rio silver February 18, 2019 2:28 pm Reply

      Sure. Taxis would take advantage of the dispatch technology if offered. But the “ride share” companies won’t allow it.


  4. Harvey February 17, 2019 10:59 am Reply

    Taxis are overpriced, and they are always more expensive than Uber. It’s new era in transportation. Deal with it. I don’t feel sorry for taxis, they have been ripping us off for decades


    1. Rio silver February 18, 2019 2:26 pm Reply

      Not true. Taxis on Kauai are cheaper than the equivalent offering from the “ride share “companies


  5. Rio Silver February 17, 2019 11:20 am Reply

    “According to Sakahara, Uber and Lyft drivers are required to comply with the same regulations and laws that apply to cab companies” but the airport doesn’t verify this information as they leave it up to Uber, and Uber’s website say it’s the responsibility of the driver to comply with insurance laws?!?! Wow! Both the airport and Uber pass the buck to the driver to make sure they are in compliance ,,,so when the S*^+ hits the fan they can say it was the drivers fault. All for what? So the ride share companies can play “basketball” with a 5 foot hoop while the other transportation, taxi and PUC, providers are playing with a 10 foot regulation height hoop? Maybe it’s time for an Uber / Lyft airport administrator!!! as it’s obvious the airports want the ride share companies to do the airports job of due diligence, checking to make sure the drivers are in compliance and act as airport administration.
    Pass the buck and pass the job to someone else, no need for airport administrative jobs anymore as they obviously don’t want to do the their jobs in the first place.


  6. Steve Martin February 17, 2019 4:38 pm Reply

    all of you would be better off to become your own business and join on with uber or lyft. i have talked with many drivers on uber that use to be cabbies and they made more money and made their own decisions on how and when they need to work. nothing is more convenient than being your own boss. make as much as you want. not controlled like the cab companies. get over the mad thing uber lyft have billions behind them they are here to stay.


    1. Rio silver February 18, 2019 2:22 pm Reply

      There is a thing called cost of carriage. It doesn’t change if your a limo, a taxi, or a transportation provider calling themselves “ride share”. After the bills are paid and the depreciation of the vehicle accounted for ride share drivers are worse off than a taxi driver driving for a company. And Uber wants to go to robot cars,,,bye bye driver no more job for you.


  7. Kauaidoug February 17, 2019 8:05 pm Reply

    This is not right what is happening to our cab drivers. As long as they have to submit papers, forms etc etc etc. Then they should have first crack at people needing rides.


    1. Rio silver February 18, 2019 2:30 pm Reply

      That’s right!
      And there is a reason why these “ride share” companies are outright illegal in many jurisdictions.


  8. shakauai February 17, 2019 8:42 pm Reply

    The taxi drivers at the airport only accept cash. If, as a business owner, you’re going to conduct your transactions like it’s 1965, not surprisingly you’re going to lose customers to a competitor who’s willing to be more flexible and catering to the preferences of today’s consumers.


    1. Rio silver February 18, 2019 2:23 pm Reply

      Not true. Many do.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.