Lawsuit: Homesick Navy officer can’t get Hawaii gun permit

HONOLULU — A U.S. Navy officer stationed in Hawaii said in a lawsuit that he can’t get a gun permit because he sought counseling for feeling depressed and homesick.

Michael Santucci’s lawsuit is the latest challenge to Hawaii’s gun ownership restrictions. His lawsuit focuses on a state law that allows access to an applicant’s medical records in determining whether someone should be allowed to own a gun, which his lawyers say is unique to Hawaii.

Santucci, a cryptologic warfare officer from Fort Myers, Florida, saw a medical provider at a military hospital for feelings of depression and homesickness a few months after arriving in Hawaii last year, according to his lawsuit, filed Sunday.

He wasn’t diagnosed with any disqualifying behavioral, emotional or mental disorder, the lawsuit said.

He later filled out forms to register his firearms with the Honolulu Police Department and indicated that he had been treated for depression, but noted is was “not serious.”

Hawaii law requires registration of all firearms. Prior to acquiring a gun, an applicant must apply for a permit. When applying, the applicant signs a waiver allowing the chief of police of the county issuing the permit access to any records that have a bearing on the mental health of an applicant, the lawsuit said.

Santucci received a letter from the police department saying that in order to process his application, he needs written certification from a psychologist or doctor documenting he’s no longer affected by any mental disorder, the lawsuit said.

Governmental physicians, such as Department of Defense personnel, are forbidden from writing such statements, Santucci’s lawyers said.

The lawsuit noted that the Navy approves of Santucci possessing firearms.

Alan Beck, one of Santucci’s attorneys, said it’s unconstitutional to require a medical evaluation to exercise a fundamental right when there’s no evidence of mental illness.

“We’re challenging the process,” Beck said.

A spokesperson for the state attorney general’s office declined to comment Wednesday because they had not yet been formally served with the complaint.

Representatives for the city and county of Honolulu, also named as a defendant, didn’t immediately respond to a message seeking comment.

“As a practical matter, the City makes the applicant disprove a negative — I am not incompetent — which is expensive and burdensome especially considering that virtually all Hawaii doctors refuse to write the waivers the City requires as proof of mental competency,” Santucci’s lawyers said in a motion for a preliminary injunction.

  1. kauaiboy April 10, 2022 5:19 am Reply

    Why does anyone willing to hire a lawyer and go to court to try to get the right to own a gun need to obtain a gun at all? Thankfully, this is not Florida where every Tom, Dick, and Harry has a gun and lives in fear.

    I have heard the argument “Guns do not kill people, people kill people” . Well, it it lost harder for anyone to kill someone if they do not possess a gun. End of story.

  2. TexLonghorn May 2, 2022 3:57 am Reply

    No one in this country needs to hire a lawyer or go to court to get the right to own a gun as we the people have the inalienable right, guaranteed by the constitution, to keep and bear arms without infringement by law enforcement or politicians. As for Florida I am sure that those law abiding citizens that choose to use their constitutionally guaranteed rights and own a firearm are not living in fear but are secure in their own personal safety. Take away the right to own guns from the honest law abiding citizen and only criminals will have them. End of story

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.