COVID committee suggests Safe Travels modification

LIHU‘E — The House Select Committee on COVID-19 Economic and Financial Preparedness has submitted a proposal to modify the state’s Safe Travels program which involves offering rapid post-arrival tests to travelers awaiting pre-travel testing results.

The committee suggested modifying the program to allow travelers without their 72-hour pre-travel test who are subject to the two-week quarantine to take a rapid test at the airport, and then once they receive a negative result from the original pre-travel test, be released from the quarantine.

The committee called the first month of the state’s Safe Travels program an “unqualified success” by public health and economic standpoints, but said the newly imposed rule that travelers must have their negative results prior to boarding a flight will be “devastating,” according to Mufi Hannemann, president and CEO of the Hawai‘i Lodging and Tourism Association.

“Every island and every report shows that room nights are being canceled,” Hannemann said. “That’ll translate to more furloughs, staffing reductions.”

One estimate the committee suggested put room night cancellations at 300-2,000 per property, the report said.

Dr. Mark Mugiishi, president and CEO of the Hawai‘i Medical Service Association, presented the plan at a meeting Monday. He said the average number of new cases per day (96.7 vs. 94.6), test positive rates (2.8 vs. 2), number of hospitalizations (103 vs. 60) and percent of intensive care unit beds occupied (53% vs. 46%) are all lower on Nov. 27 than on Oct. 11, prior to the Safe Travels program.

“If our goal is to achieve a balance between public health and economic health, then this (Safe Travels) program did exactly that,” Mugiishi, co-chair of the public health subcommittee, said.

Mayor Derek Kawakami feels otherwise when it comes down to Kaua‘i.

During the meeting, Kawakami said he agreed that Safe Travels works on a state-level, but that it’s “hard to manage the state with one size fits all (model), especially with a smaller, rural community like Kaua‘i.”

On Kaua‘i, before the Oct. 15 Safe Travels launch, the county had a total of 61 cumulative infections. Since then, the county has seen 70 new cases. Of that, 57 were travel-related, 35 who landed with negative pre-travel test and 16 who received positive pre-travel tests after arrival, Kawakami reported.

Mugiishi said the numbers weren’t “frightening,” but conceded that Kawakami and his team know more about infrastructure than he did.

“We all knew we wouldn’t have our numbers at zero,” Mugiishi said. “Even the numbers that you presented represent less than one person a day.”

One of the local rules Kawakami has suggested includes a mandatory three-day quarantine with a post-arrival test before a traveler can be set loose. This was denied by Gov. David Ige.

The average length of a vacation on Kaua‘i prior to the pandemic was about a week, two days longer than the average stay for the state, Kawakami said. During the pandemic, that average soared, growing to 30 days. Since the start of Safe Travels, Kawakami reports the average stay is about two weeks now. Based on this and the infection incubation period, Kawakami proposed that rule as common ground.

“We are concerned that we don’t have the ability to handle a big outbreak or community spread if it happens,” Kawakami said.

The committee’s suggested Safe Travels modification adds an additional screening layer, allows the tourism industry to continue and reduces the burden of quarantine enforcement, Mugiishi said.

  1. Jay Bee December 1, 2020 4:37 am Reply

    We cannot sacrifice the economy for the sake of this sickness, people are committing suicide because they can’t take the lockdowns, we need to keep with masks and social distancing but all of these restrictions are doing more harm than good. The death/infection ratio is incredibly low, this virus cannot control everything we do and how we function, people and businesses need to take responsibility for themselves and the government needs to stop these mandates, this control on or rights and freedom is not helping anyone

    1. BJ December 1, 2020 5:46 pm Reply

      Could you point me to the articles showing the suicides related to Covid?

  2. Robert s. December 1, 2020 6:47 am Reply

    Kauai travel rules are VERY confusing. It seems that residences can return to their residents, BUT tourist have to go from the airport directly to a “Safe Harbor Hotel”..
    If you are a visitor and have a private home you are renting, can you go to it directly from airport?
    Why pay for a rental home if you have to go to a designated safe harbor location?

    This is a show stopper for many visitors and no mention in the Rule 23 or any Hawaii website.

  3. Joshua Beadle December 1, 2020 8:00 am Reply

    Why is this not already in place?!?

  4. Kauaidoug December 1, 2020 9:11 am Reply

    Hurray for Mayor K! Keep it up. Nothing easy about handling a pandemic.

  5. Joe Public December 1, 2020 9:30 am Reply

    Guess that is why Mufi’s political career is over. Having the post test right after you land is useless. Give it 3-4 days, then take the test to be safe.

  6. Kauai Boy Mainland December 1, 2020 9:48 am Reply

    Dumb as you know what…

  7. Kauaidoug December 1, 2020 10:23 am Reply

    I thought Covid19 travel restrictions were for the safety of the citizens not to fill hotel beds?

  8. Laurie Napua Fagen December 1, 2020 10:25 am Reply

    I would be happy to take the rapid test! Anxious to get back to visit Kauai….

  9. WestKauai December 1, 2020 9:20 pm Reply

    How about this? Those with a negative test can board a flight to Kauai. Those with a positive or no test can not board the same flight with those that test negative? This should minimize infection of those that are not subject to quarantine under Safe Travel criteria…

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.