Hawai‘i as a kipuka: a COVID-free state where we can thrive

Editor’s note: This editorial first ran in The Honolulu Star-Advertiser as an “Island Voices” commentary on Aug. 25.

The geographical isolation of Hawai‘i and early travel quarantine protected us from the first wave of the pandemic. Yet many continue to push for lifting the quarantine and inviting visitors back in hopes of returning to the pre-COVID tourism economy.

Unfortunately, even without the uptick of visitors a reopening would bring, COVID-19 cases here have skyrocketed from 25 daily to over 200 daily in a month’s time, the fastest rate of spread anywhere in the U.S.

Experts suggest that even if Hawai‘i reopens, the number of visitors needed to be profitable will not come if their safety is not assured. To devastate the health of our communities and the integrity of our health-care system in a doomed attempt to resuscitate tourism makes no sense.

Thankfully, our volcanic islands provide a metaphor for a better way forward: a kipuka. Like islands of vegetation in the middle of barren lava, Hawai‘i can become an oasis of health and harmony in the midst of a COVID-infested world. We can choose the goal of eradicating the virus and use our geographic isolation, local culture of laulima (cooperation) and strong, kipuka-based public policies to prevent the virus from re-entering and spreading in Hawai‘i.

There is evidence here and worldwide that when the coronavirus surges, the economy shrinks. When the virus is suppressed, the economy starts to recover. The best thing we can do for the economy is to get rid of the virus.

Much is made of the fact that tourism is 35% of Hawai‘i’s economy. People forget that the non-tourism sector, 65% of Hawaii’s economy, is almost twice as large as the visitor economy.

The non-tourism economy shuts down when the coronavirus is loose in the community, but when the virus is eliminated, those with money to spend (e.g., retirees, online, essential, government and construction workers) feel free to go out to eat, visit other islands, throw weddings and parties. People get haircuts and massages, schedule dental appointments and elective surgeries, go to the movies. Mental health improves. Elderly get to see their family and friends again. Schools, from preschools to higher education, operate normally, and parents return to work without worrying about their kids.

Kaua‘i and New Zealand have both shown that a COVID-free kipuka is possible. Kaua‘i was virus-free for 65 days. New Zealand for 102 days. New Zealand used a rigorously-enforced quarantine system of 26 hotels and strategic testing to process 30,000 returning residents (the country is not yet open to visitors) without one case escaping into the community. Life went back to normal. Likewise, on Kaua‘i, after nine weeks of no new cases, residents enjoyed the freedom of relaxed restrictions, and it seemed conceivable to send our children back to school.

Unfortunately, due to Hawai‘i’s inadequate quarantine system, cases started reappearing on Kaua‘i in June. In New Zealand a family of four was recently found to be infected, and that has quickly grown into 90 cases. But according to a plan laid out ahead of time, the city of Auckland was immediately shut down and aggressive contact tracing began.

It is this kind of proactive planning and swift action toward a zero-virus goal that we need from our state and county governments. Securing and maintaining our kipuka will take a unified commitment from all of us — leaders and citizens. We cannot allow ourselves or our leaders to underestimate this virus if we want to protect our people and the economy.

May the vision of kipuka inspire us all to live with aloha, and may it instill our leaders with the kuleana (responsibility) and courage to make the tough decisions to protect our residents and grow a flourishing new economy.


Kapono Chong-Hanssen, M.D., is medical director of Ho‘ola Lahui Hawai‘i and the Kaua‘i Community Health Center. JoAnn A. Yukimura is former Kaua‘i County mayor and councilmember. They are members of the Kaua‘i COVID Discussion Group, reachable at kauaicdg@gmail.com.

  1. Da Shadow September 6, 2020 10:58 am Reply

    “sky-rocketing” cases! -from which 99%+ will experience only mild symptoms, if any.
    but let’s continue to keep the state locked down, since suicides are far more acceptable than covid deaths.

    1. Da Light September 12, 2020 7:09 am Reply

      Please cite your sources.

  2. Thomas Ohana September 6, 2020 3:04 pm Reply

    For this plan to work, residents must also stay on island without trips away from Kauai. Can they do this? Can airline staff and others be kept from their families on a daily basis? I am a resident, banned from returning because of a part time job on the mainland which pays my property taxes and mortgage. In my field of work, there is no employment in Kauai. Kauai needs to face the new reality and devise a long-term approach to dealing with this virus. Hiding is not going to work for anyone.

  3. Del Lafountain September 6, 2020 4:41 pm Reply

    In Tahoe we averaged on case every 3 days for the first 3 months. I was scared to death when we reopened. We had hundreds of thousands converging on a town of 22k. It was our busiest summer in history. At first we freaked out when the case counts went to 10-15 a day. Then the mask mandate started. We went down to 1-2 cases a day. We got through the whole summer of tourism without a single death. Many businesses were saved and many had their best summers ever. I will admit I was wrong when i fought tooth and nail to keep tourists out.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.