State plans for lifting quarantines

LIHU‘E — Beginning Aug 1, the state will implement a pretravel testing program for travelers to Hawai‘i as an alternative to the 14-day quarantine, Gov. David Ige announced Wednesday.

“We are now ready to begin the process to return our economy in a safe and healthy way,” Ige said at a briefing from inside the Daniel K. Inouye International Airport in Honolulu. “People do need to get back to work, but it needs to be in a way that protects the health of our community.”

In August, travelers who have a valid negative test prior to arriving in the state will not be subject to the quarantine. The quarantine will remain in place for those who do not wish to take a pre-travel test.

The state is working on efforts with private businesses on testing, including CVS, which is finalizing a price, Lieutenant Governor Josh Green said.

The state is also looking at establishing the negative result be within 72 hours of the flight, similar to rules adopted by Alaska.

Temperatures screenings will continue in this new plan. Those who clock in at 100.4 or above and those experiencing other coronavirus symptoms will have a secondary screening and test.

On Friday, the legislature will vote on Senate Bill No. 126 that will appropriate funds toward new protocol measures including a thermal screen program at the airport, web-based traveler application, screening and testing facilities as well as supplies for airport officials, State House Speaker Scott K. Saiki said during the briefing.

Green explained that a pre-test will minimize the risk of COVID-19 coming into the state. “We’ve been able to keep the fatality and the illness at bay,” Green said.

On Wednesday, the state reported 16 new cases of COVID-19. Thirteen in O‘ahu, one on the Big Island and two from Hawai‘i residents, one in Nevada and the other in Arizona. Hawai‘i has the lowest number of confirmed cases per capita in the country with 835 people who have tested positive for COVID-19 since March, and about 686 recoveries.

Ige first implemented a self-quarantine in mid-March, which has been instrumental in curbing the virus but has also sparked great economic downturn in a state where tourism is the leading industry. Over 200,000 residents have filed for unemployment since March.

On Tuesday, 1,512 people arrived in the state, including 409 visitors, 454 returning residents and 185 military members, according to the Hawai‘i Tourism Authority. The state continues to work on travel bubbles with Japan, South Korea, Australia and New Zealand.

More cases are anticipated as sanctions expire, but the state has increased testing and contact tracing capacity. “With an increase in COVID cases, our health care system will not be overwhelmed,” Ige said.

The state is able to process between 4,000 to 5,000 cases per today, with a one-day turn around on O‘ahu and next day for neighbor islands, Department of Health Director Bruce Anderson said. And over 600 contact tracers can monitor 20 people at a time.

Anderson said wearing masks, hand-washing, staying at home while sick and social distancing are still the most important steps to limiting the spread of the virus.

Tuesday night, the Department of Justice issued a statement of interest challenging the constitutionality of Ige’s out-of-state traveler quarantine.

Ige said he did not announce this plan Wednesday because of the DOJ’s statement.

The DOJ states that the quarantine “effectively discriminates against out-of-state residents,” partially because of the lifted travel sanctions for inter-island travelers.

“This effective discrimination, based on the evidence and argument presented thus far, appears to be inadequately tailored to further public safety and therefore does not comply with the Constitution,” the statement reads.

The statement, submitted by Assistant Attorney General Eric Dreiband of the Civil Rights Division, Deputy Assistant Attorney General Alexander Maugeri and U.S. Attorney Kenji Price of the District of Hawai‘i, supports the lawsuit filed by Nevada and California residents who own property in Hawai‘i.

Earlier this month, a dozen Kaua‘i residents with one Hawai‘i Island resident represented by the Attorneys for Freedom of Law Firm filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of Ige’s emergency orders, naming the state, Ige and Attorney General Clare Connors in the suit.

In the statement of interest, the DOJ compared Hawai‘i to Alaska, which has less implemented restrictive quarantine mandates.

While Alaska also enforces a 14-day quarantine, out-of-state residents can waive it by testing negative for COVID-19 before their flight, quarantining until they receive a negative test result after landing or by providing evidence of a coronavirus recovery. Similar to what Ige announced Wednesday.

“Reasonable measures designed to protect the public are not only appropriate, but responsible during a pandemic, and the Constitution does not bind the hands of state officials who, through careful thought and deliberation impose such measures,” Price said. “However, there are bounds to the discretion our public officials have during times of crisis.”

Saiki targeted Price, saying this undermines the credibility of his office.

“Governor Ige’s 14-day quarantine order is not discriminatory because it applies to all travelers,” Saiki said. “Mr. Price’s opposition to the quarantine disregards the health and safety of Hawaiʻi’s residents and economy. Mr. Price’s action has unfortunately undermined the credibility and objectivity of the Office of the U.S. Attorney.”

Connors echoed this during the briefing, saying that the state quarantine and other emergency rules are fully in compliance with the law.

The federal case is Carmichael, et al. v. Ige, Case No. 1:20-cv-00273 JAO-WRP.

•••

Sabrina Bodon, public safety and government reporter, can be reached at 245-0441 or sbodon@thegardenisland.com.

7 Comments
  1. J.D. June 25, 2020 5:02 am Reply

    A virus has to run it’s course. Experts say until 80% of the community has built up antibodies you will have problems. We need to protect the vulnerable, wash hands stay home when sick etc. Closing the state only prolonged the agony. In over 99% of the people it is like a mild flu. Many people are not aware they had it.


  2. Palani June 25, 2020 7:09 am Reply

    The Hawaiian government (State and county) has for a long time and increasingly discriminated against non-resident property owners. It’s time for the owners to band together and defend themselves. Not all non-resident owners are rich, not all are exploiting Hawaii, all are being exploited by the Hawaiian government.


  3. kauaiboy June 25, 2020 9:13 am Reply

    “The state is also looking at establishing the negative result be within 72 hours of the flight”.

    Family in California want to come in August and not have to quarantine. They are willing to pay for testing. THE PROBLEM IS THAT THEY CANNOT FIND A TESTING FACILITY IN THE BAY AREA THAT WILL GUARANTEE TEST RESULTS WITHIN 72 HOURS.

    SOMETHING HAS TO GIVE!


    1. Kika June 26, 2020 9:21 am Reply

      We have plans to come August 5th, we checked with our state health department. They said we can only be testing if we have symptoms and can’t find out how long it takes to get the results. So, now what do we do?


  4. Joshua Beadle June 25, 2020 6:13 pm Reply

    Who will verify the legitimacy of these 72 hour CV tests? Seems pretty easy to forge a test result which fools the amazing Kauai airport staff. Anyone with a computer and printer can create a fake lab result.
    Also, you do understand that your skin will register 4-5 degrees cooler than your internal body temperature. That means when using a Non-contact thermometer, a reading of 98 degrees indicates a high fever. I’ll bet a dollar the local airport staff will have no training to know this and other details. Same goes for TSA.
    God help our little Island, our government and institutions are failing us. Plant a garden and avoid businesses who cater to tourists. Look at AZ, FL and TX to see how this story goes for us when political / economic pressures steer healthcare decisions.


  5. cricketttt June 26, 2020 12:00 am Reply

    I am a long time, off-Island owner (1967) of a small beach house, who is very tired of the discrimination I have faced over the years of my ownership. I would like to join your group, hoping that we can gain a voice, after being silenced for so many years. My family history goes back to the bombing of Pearl Harbor. I have been trying to save this piece of very sweet history for my children and grandchildren, who have cherished their memories of old Hawaii, Aunties and Uncles who made Kauai so special to them, and their dad’s, grandparents, and great grandparents life there. I am sad that those of us who love Kauai have no protection from the bitter elements who no longer want us to exist. It’s has been a sad commentary to the beautiful life that we once shared. I am being taxed out of existence, and now this! I am not rich or famous; Just a lucky person who took a chance on Kauai when it was a dot on the map. It has been my happy place, and I would like to see it remain like that for my family. Hopefully, we can do something collectively to make life better for all.


    1. wut June 27, 2020 12:00 am Reply

      don’t live here don’t own here


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.