Kauai Fisherman J. G. Wyman’s hard luck

On Saturday, Nov. 11, 1905, J. G. Wyman, an elderly, penniless fisherman from Kauai, was sentenced in Honolulu to 24 hours confinement at Oahu Prison by U. S. District Court Judge Sanford Ballard Dole for contempt, because he’d failed to obey a subpoena summoning him to Honolulu for jury duty.

His failure resulted in his being arrested on Kauai under a bench warrant and brought to Honolulu by Deputy Marshal Winter, where he appeared in court in a cheap suit provided to him by the court for the occasion – a substitute for his shabby fisherman’s clothes.

“I had no money to travel with and couldn’t come,” he pled to Judge Dole, who had formerly been the president of the Provisional Government of Hawaii and the Republic of Hawaii, and the first governor of the Territory of Hawaii.

Wyman also went on to explain how that was so – that he’d not caught enough fish to pay for his steamer fare and “I didn’t try to borrow the money, because I had no means of repaying, as far as I could see.”

Judge Dole then asked District Attorney Breckons for his advice and Breckons replied that Wyman should have notified officials if he couldn’t have come. Had he sent a notice, some arrangements could have been made for Wyman to travel to Honolulu.

Dole concurred with Breckons and ordered Wyman imprisoned for 24 hours, his justification being that summonses of the court must be respected.

Breckons then proposed to Dole that Wyman should also be fined to reimburse the government expense incurred for bringing him to Honolulu, but upon being informed that Wyman was absolutely broke, he withdrew his suggestion.

When Wyman was released from prison on the following day, Sunday, he faced the prospect of not being able to return to his home on Kauai, where he’d eked out a living by catching fish, since he had no funds to pay for steamer fare and little hope of earning cash to do so in Honolulu.

What became of him afterwards is unknown.

Hank Soboleski has been a resident of Kauai since the 1960s. Hank’s love of the island and its history has inspired him, in conjunction with The Garden Island Newspaper, to share the island’s history weekly. The collection of these articles can be found here: https://bit.ly/2IfbxL9 and here https://bit.ly/2STw9gi Hank can be reached at hssgms@gmail.com

  1. harry oyama January 2, 2020 2:15 am Reply

    Sanford Ballard Dole, was just another racist rubber stamp traitor, part of illegal overthrow of Hawaii’s sovereign nation by racist white men of the missionaries who continued to oppress poor native Hawaiians, in this case an honest, honorable poor fisherman who barely could scratch out a living in turn as a result of this overthrow of native Hawaiians who held such occupation with honor and esteen, rather than to set an example of those barbarian white racists in charge, picking on the weak and helpless.

    In the same manner as another white racist judge who in contrast, “sentenced” Thelma Macie and her racist white Navy officer to one hour of tea time of “punishment” in his chambers for the murder of a native Hawaiian man on false trumped up charges that he and two others “raped” Thelma, a rather loose, alcoholic Navy wife with a bad reputation of fooling around with Navy officers.

    Makes you wonder why locals hate white people for what they represent.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.