Kapaa man gets 10 years for break-in

LIHUE — A Kapaa man was sentenced to 10 years in jail last week for breaking into the home of his former boss and hacking thousands of dollars worth of appliances and furniture to pieces with a machete because, as he explained to police, “He owes me choke ahi.”

Forrest Broyles’ former boss was watching TV with his wife on the evening of Dec. 3 when he heard a horn honking and a loud bang on the side of the house, followed moments later by yelling and screaming and the sound of the glass on his front door shattering, according to a written statement by a Kauai Police Department detective who responded to the scene.

The man looked over the second-floor banister and saw Broyles walking toward him up the stairs, carrying a machete.

“Forrest started hitting the television with the machete,” the man told police, according to a written statement by a detective who responded to the Kapaa home. “Forrest broke out all the windows, the sliding door, broke the living room stand chairs, the table, kitchen cabinets, the stove and microwave, canoe paddle among other things.”

All told, Broyles, 25, caused over $3,000 in damage, which he will have to pay restitution for after his release from prison. He was sentenced to 10 years in jail for first-degree burglary, five years for criminal property damage, another five for terroristic threatening and a year for third-degree assault.

The prison terms will run concurrently, meaning Broyles will be incarcerated for a decade at most. The burglary charge carries a mandatory minimum sentence of three years, four months. He pleaded no contest in May to three felonies and a misdemeanor assault charge, which prosecutors reduced from attempted-murder in exchange for the plea.

According to a statement Broyles made to police who arrived on the scene, the dispute arose out of a disagreement over fish.

“He is my fishing buddy,” Broyles is quoted as saying in the detective’s report. “He owes me ahi. That is what the whole incident was about.”

Broyles went on to tell the detective that he slapped his former boss across the back with his machete but said the threats he made — the owner of the home told police that Broyles said “he was going to kill him and chop him up.” — were just an act, “because I am an orange belt and I know not to take life.”

“I am on Ayahuasca,” Broyles then told the detective, who described the powerful substance, used in ritualistic South American tribal ceremonies, as a peyote-type hallucinogenic. “You can’t charge me with any felonies because I am a Native American warrior.”

A May 8 article in The Garden Island about Broyles case got the attention of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, an organization widely considered to be the highest profile animal rights group in the country.

About a week after the TGI article, PETA’s executive vice president, Tracy Reiman, sent a letter addressed to the director of the Hawaii Department of Public Safety and Kauai Community Correctional Center, asking that Broyles be placed on a “flesh-free diet.”

“The actions that Mr. Broyles is being incarcerated for caused his former fishing accomplice to experience fear and trauma,” Reiman wrote. “But the actions that started this whole dispute — hooking terrified animals through the mouth, dragging them into an environment in which they cannot breathe, and killing them — did the same to other sentient beings.”

It is possible that PETA’s concerns are somewhat misplaced in this instance. A 2017 Drug Enforcement Administration intelligence report lists “fish” as a slang word for two different forms of cocaine.

  1. jake August 13, 2019 7:08 am Reply

    You local “boyz” just don’t get it do you? If you’re over 12 and you threaten or hit people, you go to prison.

  2. Jeff Pens August 13, 2019 8:18 am Reply

    this is a poorly written article that makes just about as much sense as mr. bryoles.

  3. Art I August 13, 2019 8:29 am Reply

    Respectfully, how the last paragraph

    “It is possible that PETA’s concerns are somewhat misplaced in this instance. A 2017 Drug Enforcement Administration intelligence report lists “fish” as a slang word for two different forms of cocaine.”

    might be interpreted is not good journalism. You might consider not just editing and re-releasing the article, but issuing a retraction and correction. The homeowners might have grounds for taking legal action against you otherwise.

  4. 808bangahz August 13, 2019 10:33 am Reply

    must’ve been some good ahi

  5. Thad miller August 13, 2019 4:44 pm Reply

    To Forest’s Boss.
    I stopped him from killing he’s mom in 2017. And got beat by this man child .He got a yr then to get out to do this.Iam glad you and your wife is ok.
    He needs alot of help .

  6. Me August 13, 2019 6:58 pm Reply

    There is way more to this situation that will never be told. I know the owner of the house and he is not vengeful but forgiving. Under the influence of anything is just that no matter what origin u from

  7. Kauaiian August 14, 2019 11:12 pm Reply

    Wow. The last paragraph came out of left field. Did I miss the part of this incident where there was confirmed drug use or drug dealing happening between BOTH parties in this incident, and that is what gave you guys the idea to make a accusatory statement about DEA and cocoaine? Seriously? Is there any fact checking done prior to publishing these articles? Any legal consultation done beforehand to make sure the words being printed are not slandering?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.