Breaking News

Breaking News

Sine Die — My take on the 2019 session

The bill to increase minimum wage died, so there will be no increase.

HB1326 (corporate water theft) also died, so A&B does not get a $62 million benefit (yet).

We should be pleased with the outcome of HB1326 as it is a huge victory on many levels. But we should be angry, sad, and more determined than ever to reverse the inaction on minimum wage.

A subsistence wage is $17, according to Hawaii’s Department of Business and Economic Development. Both the House and the Senate and the governor have stated publicly they supported a $15 per hour increase, phased in over time. But instead, the minimum wage will remain stuck at $10.10.

It is shameful really. Though legislators and government administrators will all be getting their raises, regular low income working people will get nothing — zero.

Our state Legislature dominated by lawmakers who were elected under the flag of the Democratic Party of Hawaii (DPH), refused to pass legislation increasing the minimum wage, a top legislative priority of their own party.

This my friends is the definition of a DINO (Democrat In Name Only). The vast majority of legislators have all professed to support not only increasing the minimum wage to at least $15, but ultimately to a living wage. But when the crunch comes, the answer is “Shoots, we ran out of time. ” Or, “I’m not sure what happened, we couldn’t get Finance Committee clearance.”

I respect those who are willing to publicly defend their opposition, but that is the small minority. The majority, don’t have the courage of their convictions and instead prefer hiding behind the skirts of leadership, who dutifully carry out the will of the majority and kill the bill.

This issue alone should be enough to fuel the coming 2020 revolution.

But it gets worse.

Not one measure of substance dealing with climate change was passed. Not one. The defining issue of our generation, an issue upon which the entire planet’s future is based — and there is not a peep out of our state Legislature.

Dedicated funding for education — failed.

Banning of single use Styrofoam food containers — failed.

Legalization of cannabis for responsible adult use — failed.

Automatic voter registration — failed.

Banning of candy flavored tobacco products — failed.

Regulating “Pay Day Lenders” — failed

The Legislature did pass measures to fund the construction of a new sports stadium to the tune of $350 million.

They also passed a measure to allow platforms such as Airbnb and HomeAway to collect taxes from both legal and illegal transient vacation rental properties.

Or as Josh Frost in his blog Regarding Frost, Sine Die put it:

“The legislature approved a measure, SB1292, which taxes illegal vacation rentals. It doesn’t stop them or in any way regulate them. It simply taxes them. So, in a shameless effort to add $42 million to the state coffers, the legislature ignored pleas from communities infected with short-term rentals and their effect on our affordable housing crisis.”

Sine Die 2019

There is some genuine good news, including that the legislature did in fact pass “All Mail-In Voting”, expanded the opportunities for HEMP farming, and made some good initial steps in the direction of criminal justice and bail reform.

But at the end of the day, the 2019 legislative session failed us on far too many levels.

We deserve so much more. Serving at the legislature is not just bringing home pork to the district, road repaving, lifeguards, and school sidewalks. It’s also about changing public policy for the greater good.

So when legislators brag about the money they “brought home”, make sure you ask them about what policy changes they championed, and whether or not they stood up for low income working men and women.

We need to look at our own district Representative and our District Senator, and ask the tough questions. What did they actually do?

Did they dodge the issue of raising the minimum wage or did they speak out and make their position known and public? Are they a DINO? Do they sincerely believe in the core principals of economic justice? Do they believe that climate change is real and that we have a responsibility as individuals and as a State to deal with it?

Full disclaimer: I am the elected Vice Chair of the Democratic Party of Hawaii (DPH) and a member of the Democratic National Committee (DNC). However, my thoughts and writings reflect my personal opinion, and I do not speak here as an official representative of the Party.

For me, this is not about Party, it’s about values. Candidates should run for office wearing a Party label that reflects their personal values. Candidates should read the Party platform and understand that when they sign their agreement to that platform, that it is supposed to mean something.


Gary Hooser formerly served in the state Senate, where he was majority leader. He also served for eight years on the Kauai County Council and was former director of the state Office of Environmental Quality Control. He serves presently in a volunteer capacity as board president of the Hawaii Alliance for Progressive Action (HAPA) and is executive director of the Pono Hawaii In

  1. RG DeSoto May 8, 2019 11:19 am Reply

    “The legislature approved a measure, SB1292, which taxes illegal vacation rentals. It doesn’t stop them or in any way regulate them. It simply taxes them. So, in a shameless effort to add $42 million to the state coffers, the legislature ignored pleas from communities infected with short-term rentals and their effect on our affordable housing crisis.”
    Perhaps you & Frost would care to cite the studies that prove there is a positive statistical correlation between the number of TVRs and rental rates that affect those who are in the “affordable” category.
    Here is some information on statistical correlation, Gary:
    “The correlation coefficient is a measure that determines the degree to which two variables’ movements are associated. The most common correlation coefficient, generated by the Pearson product-moment correlation, may be used to measure the linear relationship between two variables. However, in a non-linear relationship, this correlation coefficient may not always be a suitable measure of dependence.
    The range of values for the correlation coefficient is -1.0 to 1.0. In other words, the values cannot exceed 1.0 or be less than -1.0 whereby a correlation of -1.0 indicates a perfect negative correlation, and a correlation of 1.0 indicates a perfect positive correlation. Anytime the correlation coefficient, denoted as r, is greater than zero, it’s a positive relationship. Conversely, anytime the value is less than zero, it’s a negative relationship. A value of zero indicates that there is no relationship between the two variables.
    In the financial markets, correlation coefficient is used to measure the correlation between two securities. When two stocks, for example, move in the same direction, the correlation coefficient is positive. Conversely, when two stocks move in opposite directions, the correlation coefficient is negative.
    If the correlation coefficient of two variables is zero, it signifies that there is no linear relationship between the variables. However, this is only for a linear relationship; it is possible that the variables have a strong curvilinear relationship.
    When the value of r is close to zero, generally between -0.1 and +0.1, the variables are said to have no linear relationship or a very weak linear relationship. For example, suppose the prices of coffee and of computers are observed and found to have a correlation of +.0008; this means that there is no correlation, or relationship, between the two variables.
    Positive Correlation
    A positive correlation, when the correlation coefficient (r) is greater than 0, signifies that both variables move in the same direction or are correlated. When r is +1, it signifies that the two variables being compared have a perfect positive relationship; when one variable moves higher or lower, the other variable moves in the same direction with the same magnitude.
    The closer the value of r is to +1, the stronger the linear relationship. For example, suppose the value of oil prices are directly related to the prices of airplane tickets, with a correlation coefficient of +0.8. The relationship between oil prices and airfares has a very strong positive correlation since the value is close to +1. So if the price of oil decreases, airfares follow in tandem. If the price of oil increases, so does the prices of airplane tickets.”
    Put up or clam up about this issue,
    RG DeSoto

  2. Dt May 8, 2019 1:44 pm Reply

    Hi Gary,

    I am a little confused. Why not put the decision in the hands of the people (voting public) instead of in the hands of the legislation to pass a bill?

    Respectfully thankful,

  3. Amused May 8, 2019 4:47 pm Reply

    Gary, if the Dems can’t get things passed through a Democratic legislature, maybe it speaks to the poor quality of your leadership. As for values, yours are dubious and certainly don’t reflect my own as a Democrat.

  4. WestKauai May 12, 2019 5:52 pm Reply


    When I took my first job at age 14 or thereabouts, I did not expect to be paid enough to pay for a home, raise a family, or whatever. I was happy with the dollar per hour or so I received. After all, this was an opportunity to enter the job market with absolutely no prior training or skills to speak of. Later, when I joined the Marines, I was okay with $95.50 per month, as food and housing were provided as well. The minimum wage was meant to be simply that, a minimum wage, not a subsistence wage.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.