Cost still grounds curbside recycling

  • Jessica Else / The Garden Island

    Lihue resident Cesar Aguilar sorts his glass recycling at the Kauai Recycles drop bin behind the old Big Kmart.

LIHUE — Chris Valin has been combing three sides of the island for nearly four years, operating a private, curbside recycling service.

He spends his days driving around Kauai, piling pitted plastics and sticky cans into his truck and then taking them off to one of the transfer centers that accepts commercial waste.

Many of his customers are residents who would like to save the time and hassle it takes to take care of it themselves, which entails driving to one of the eight Kauai Recycles drop bins around the island.

“There’s a cost, but it does save you time and is more convenient,” Valin said. “There used to be a few other guys doing it in the past.”

The cost varies, but is about $30 a month for residential customers.

Curbside recycling success depends on a highly concentrated residential customer base and a healthy dose of commercial customers. Kauai County piloted a curbside recycling program in 2011.

That year, the pilot served 1,300 residents in the Puhi and central Lihue neighborhoods and had a participation rate of 53 percent. On average, the pilot program collected 28 pounds of recyclables per household per month.

“Specially marked, 96-gallon refuse carts accepted all the recyclables that are collected in the Kauai Recycles drop bins,” said Deputy County Engineer Lyle Tabata. “Carts were serviced every other week.”

In total, 223 tons of materials were collected during the pilot, with mixed paper topping the list at 62 tons, 28 percent of the total. Cardboard followed with 27 percent of the total, 60 tons. Newspaper was third on the list at 35 tons with 15 percent of the total.

The majority of those surveyed after the pilot was finished said they recycled more as a result of curbside recycling. Seventy-three percent said they recycled more and 16 percent said they started recycling because of the curbside recycling pilot.

“A significant challenge of the pilot was the inability to conduct islandwide promotion and education, since the pilot served only a fraction of the population,” Tabata said.

The pilot was stopped after one year and wasn’t expanded because Kauai doesn’t have the right facility to sort the mixed stream of recyclables collected in curbside bins.

That facility is called a Materials Recovery Facility (MRF), and there was a time when building it was on the books for Kauai.

It was part of the vision when the county built the Kauai Resource Center, which opened in 2002 and used $2.2 million in federal funding. Though designed for reuse and recycling, the county’s invitations for bids on operating the project failed and it was turned into a mixed-use building to “further its recycling programs.”

“The KRC has been a recycling center off and on for approximately a decade,” Tabata said.

It houses office space for two county HI5 recycling specialists, is a household battery recycling drop point, is a distribution point for backyard composting bins and provides storage for recycling supplies.

In April, a HI5 redemption center operated by Reynolds Recycling is set to open at the KRC.

Turning the MRF into the KRC would cost the county upwards of $8.3 million, based on current estimates.

In 2016, the county started on a MRF design and feasibility study that included an environmental assessment.

“If the KRC were to become a MRF, it would need to be retrofitted to raise the roof of the main building, add roofing between buildings, and other major modifications that are included in the $8.3 million estimate,” Tabata said.

After that, officials say the MRF would cost about $1 million annually to run, on top of costs to purchase recycling carts and collection trucks.

“There is no federal funding available for the MRF,” Tabata said. “Implementation of curbside recycling has been tabled due to costs.”

But, there will be some curbside recycling chatter coming up as county officials start on the update of the Integrated Solid Waste Management Plan this year.

“It is anticipated that curbside recycling and curbside green waste collection — three-cart system — will be evaluated in depth during the planning process,” Tabata said.

The cost to residents will be part of the discussion, which may be a deterrent.

“People would like to not pay for it,” he said. “If the county wanted to support it, they’d have to put money into it. If you reach a critical mass point, enough people buying in, it could work.”


Jessica Else, environment reporter, can be reached at 245-0452 or

  1. randy kansas February 10, 2019 2:58 am Reply

    am I wrong here, how come the Kauai recycle center does not pay me “per can” or item like its marked on the item ($.05 cents I think) and instead weighs them ? seems like I am getting short changed;

    is it just me…..or has anyone else had this happen ? maybe I am doing it wrong ?


    1. Bruce Iverson April 9, 2019 4:40 pm Reply

      Aloha Randy, I don’t know how it operated before Reynolds opened up at KRC, but now if you want to be paid by count all you need to do is ask them to count. They will count up to 200. If you have more than that they can weigh the rest, or you can go back around into the line to have more counted. Paying by weight should “generally” equal the same amount. The amount per pound is set by the state, and all recyclers must adhere to that. If your containers are larger, it will pay to have them weighed, if small or lightweight it may be better to have them counted. Best regards, Reynolds Recycling

  2. Jake February 10, 2019 6:09 am Reply

    You will pay for it regardless. There is no free lunch in life.

    If the county does not charge you directly to recycle, then it will be taken out of the General Fund….your taxes. You will pay.

    Stop the madness!! We are in the middle of the Pacific Ocean and it costs more money to “recycle” than to put it in the landfill. Just put it all in the garbage container, and put it in the landfill.

    Half of all recyclables collected are put in the landfills anyway.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.