Lawmakers suspicious on whale beachings

LIHUE — The five pilot whales that died on Kalapaki Beach after the Oct. 13 stranding weren’t diseased and some are questioning whether there’s a connection with the state’s Lehua Island rat poisoning project or military sonar.

Scientists briefed the House committee on Energy and Environmental Protection and the committee on Ocean, Marine Resources and Hawaiian Affairs on Tuesday on their findings from necropsies of five whales that beached themselves on Kauai.

At the briefing, scientists said the whales had full bellies of squid and fish, which is unusual for strandings.

That triggered questions about whether feeding habits near Lehua Island poisoned the animals.

“I’m so suspicious there will be a cover up. It’s too coincidental that so soon after the rat poison is dropped, we have this stranding,” said Rep. Dee Morikawa (D-16). “These whales eat the squid that may have eaten the poison dropped in the ocean. That is what I suspect happened.”

The state’s project to rid Lehua Island of non-native rats involved dropping rodenticide-laced cereal bait pellets from a helicopter onto the island in three waves — on Aug. 23, Aug. 30 and Sept. 12.

“If the whales passed Ni’ihau and saw a lot of dead fish and squid, they’d have a field day eating them and that’s what I’m suspecting happened. I could be wrong. I hope I’m wrong,” Morikawa said. “I want to make sure we have an agency we can trust looking into this and getting the correct information out.”

Rep. Jimmy Tokioka (D-14) also attended the briefing and raised questions about a potential poisoned food chain causing the whales to strand.

Included in the panel was Kristi West, who directs necropsy and cause of death investigations for whales throughout Hawaii as a research scientist and affiliate faculty member at the Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology, University of Hawaii.

“What we do know is we’re looking at an acute cause,” West said. “We’ve been able to rule out sickness and disease in the five animals, though unfortunately we don’t know about the others.”

West said now that she is aware of the possibility of the rat poison be passed on by ingesting the squid, it will also be tested.

Tokioka asked if there was any evidence that the whales had been harmed from acoustic trauma from sonar.

David Schofield, the Marine Mammal Health and Stranding Response Coordinator for NOAA Fisheries, Pacific Islands Region Office, said no. He said there is no evidence to support that. He said the U.S. Navy reported that no training took place using sonar within five miles and 24 hours of the stranding.

West said there is a population of about 19,500 pilot whales in the waters within 200 miles of the Hawaiian Islands and on average, one pilot whale dies from stranding a year.

In the Kauai case, 17 pilot whales were beached, five died and the rest returned to the open ocean.

Schofield said there has been an increase in strandings over time due to stress from pollutants in the oceans.

“What we use on the land ends up in the sea,” Schofield said.

Four different groups of pilot whales live around the Hawaiian Islands, she said, and three of them are resident to specific areas. The fourth is pelagic and moves throughout the open ocean around the islands.

The 17 whales that moved into Kalapaki Bay on Oct. 13 were most likely part of that open ocean population and didn’t have any infectious diseases, according to West.

According to the necropsy findings, four of the whales were mature — which is older than nine years of age for pilot whales — and one male was immature. The largest whale was a 14.4–foot male and the smallest was a 9.5-foot female.

In addition to looking at biotoxins, disease and sickness as a driver for the stranding event, West said other causes for pilot whale strandings could be entanglement with debris and boats, and anthropogenic noise such as sonar and echosounders.

Distilling whether underwater noise, such as sonar or other anthropogenic noise, affected the animals will take time because scientists have to wait four months for the animals’ inner ear bones to decalcify for testing.

“We’re looking at a delay in having the results interpreted,” West said.

No evidence of entanglement was found, but scientists did find 15 pounds of plastics and other debris in the largest male pilot whale’s digestive tract.

“He was still in good body condition, but it probably would have been debilitating to him in the long run,” West said.

The largest female whale had extensive bleeding along her body wall at the time of necropsy, and scientists believe this could be attributed to the breaching and ramming activity associated with the stranding.

“We have reports of some (whales) hitting the rocks and breaching and we think that would explain that level of physical blunt trauma,” West said.

It could take a year for the picture to fill in, scientists say and a case is never truly closed since samples are archived and can be tested at later dates.

“My goal here is to get answers as well,” West said. “Lots more information will be trickling in.”

Rep. Chris Lee (Kailua, Waimanalo), chair of the Energy &Environmental Protection committee and Rep. Kaniela Ing (Kihei, Wailea, Makena), chair of the Committee on Ocean, Marine Resources &Hawaiian Affairs, held the briefing after hearing public and cultural concerns about the stranding of the whales.

“It’s important that we look into these type of stranding to see what effects human pesticides, debris and noise have on the wildlife in our oceans,” Lee said. “And to see what can be done to prevent this type of thing in the future.”

Ing asked about the possible cause of this stranding.

“When marine mammals strand themselves it’s usually a signal that something in our environment is out of sync,” said Ing.

  1. ruthann jones November 29, 2017 5:32 am Reply

    If this is due to the poison drop on Lehua, I suggest criminal charges be brought on those who insisted on the action before thoroughly researching the side effects on other marine and human life. Such shame to those who ignored the outcries of those protesting this action and who even pointed out less dangerous alternatives!

    1. rollin frost December 4, 2017 12:00 pm Reply

      Are you immune from investigation and punishment when you have a government job ? To fix so much of our pollution problems of our food, and ocean is a daunting task…I do it. But if those in a government slot are not held accountable for stupidity and incompetance what can we do ? We encourage these idots by giving them immunity from evil deeds they do.

    2. Debra Kekaualua December 10, 2017 11:40 am Reply

      E’o! government bullies should all be tagged, courted and incarcerated. Corporates ousted and Huli this corruption so vast in this group of fake state hawaii. Next Election, NO precincts will be open so american hawaiian citizens CAN vote. If you vote in any of U.S. rigged gigs YOU are the problem and YOU have choices, Clinton or trump? Really!!

  2. Amused November 29, 2017 7:35 am Reply

    Sad to see Dee getting so hysterical and spreading rumors and speculation before the results are fully in. As for Ing, what does he know about whales and their behavior?

    1. rollin frost December 4, 2017 12:11 pm Reply


  3. manongindashadow November 29, 2017 8:58 am Reply

    Come on give me a break! They (Gov’t Lawmakers) suspect sonar at PMRF and rat poisoning at Lehua Island. What next? A dime in the ocean!

  4. Steve Martin November 29, 2017 12:54 pm Reply

    Thanks Dee… Put the pressure on. They could have done the job without any poisons. This whole thing would not have gone nowhere if they had used the alternate method of birth control. I like the criminal charge ideas. There is no excuse for using poison anywhere on our environment since there is a better way. No dead birds or fish period.

  5. Pete Antonson November 29, 2017 1:58 pm Reply

    I’m really disappointed in Morikawa who I felt held some good potential. This is the second time she has shot off her mouth in irresponsible speculation based on nothing. It brings to mind two thoughts:
    1. SHUT UP!

  6. Katie November 29, 2017 3:47 pm Reply

    I didn’t know there were any squid in our nearby waters. I thought that’s why albatross had to fly such long distances to feed on squid in order to feed their chicks? Why is Dee just scrambling for something to blame this on Lehua?

  7. Lloyd Good November 30, 2017 7:12 am Reply

    FIVE months later and they “WILL” check for the rat poison in their stomachs; meaning they have not done it yet. All you need to know. They have also not yet tested for ear damage from SONAR because “they have to wait four months for the inner ear bones to decalcify?????” Four months would be a month ago. No Navy testing within 24 hours is absolutely absurd. To deafen a Cetacean is to blind a cetacean. They can wander around for weeks without the ability to find food or navigate at night, and then finally beach themselves out of exhaustion and starvation. Cetaceans do not beach themselves to die. They beach themselves to live a little longer. These whales had full stomachs. The largest had a stomach full of 15 pounds of plastic. This could mean its sonar was destroyed and it was starving. Cetaceans do not eat plastic because they mistake it for fish. They eat plastic because they are starving. When their SONAR is destroyed by a percussive or acoustic blast they can not catch food and will eventually starve. Marine Mammals are highly social beings. They do not abandon each other and will hold a sick member up to the surface to breathe for weeks. This requires around the clock cooperation and will exhaust the entire pod resulting in everyone having to beach. One sick whale can cause the death of the entire family. Because their stomachs were full the cause was something more immediate…… like poison.

    1. rollin frost December 4, 2017 12:09 pm Reply

      Loyd speaks truth and wisdom.

  8. Janice Viesel December 1, 2017 3:55 pm Reply

    Remember the story of living in a small canoe… Our planet Earth. Poison anywhere is not healthy for any living being… Including humans. Poisoning the rats was the stupidest thing! That could have been dealt with in another way. Poison is called that because it’s meant to kill. The navy doing sonar testing… Another stupid move.. Allowing GMO’S to leach into the ocean… GMO’S shouldn’t even be in Paradice period….Another stupid move.. Greed is killing the earth & if humans… Don’t stand up to these greedy abusers.. We are not doing our job protecting the Earth & all life forms from the dangers of greed. What kind of earth do you want to leave for your children & their children’s children? RESPECT FOR ALL LIFE IS VITAL! Stop the greed.. Stop the killing!

  9. rollin frost December 4, 2017 12:07 pm Reply

    we all know blood thinning warfarin…the whale had internal bleeding yet another government idiot will delay to check calcium in ears ?? They try cover up incompetant fellow “civil servant-can’t fire me” and protect them from judgements about what they did ! These people are the cause, not the help !

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.