Lava Tube torch passed from Kaua‘i County Council to BOE

For defying the state Office of Information Practices’ directives to make public the minutes and audiotape of the meeting at which charter schools director Jim Shon was fired in September, the Hawai‘i state Board of Education is the 2007 recipient of the Big Island Press Club’s Lava Tube Award.

Lava Tube awards are presented annually to recognize the worst examples of openness in the state.

The Board of Education eventually released minutes of the closed-door meeting, revealing how individual members voted on Shon’s firing, but not until after the November general election when several members were seeking re-election. The audio tape of the meeting is still being withheld by the board despite repeated notices that its refusal to release the tape is illegal.

Also this year the Press Club is presenting its Torch of Light award, recognizing the best example of openness in Hawai‘i, to West Hawaii Today for uncovering and reporting on a previously secret case in the state Judiciary.

The Press Club’s board of directors has presented these awards annually since 1997.

Since being informed by the OIP on Oct. 30, 2006, that it must comply with the state’s open meetings law, the Board of Education has continually thwarted the public’s right to know by refusing to make the tape available upon request without charging excessive and illegal fees. The board told Larry Geller, a citizen who requested a copy of the tape, that it would cost $880 to transcribe the tape of the meeting in order to redact portions that were not required to be released.

OIP Director Les Kondo informed the Board in December, and again as recently as March 8, that charging a fee for transcribing the tape is illegal under Hawai‘i law.

Board President Karen Knudsen said the Board is incapable of producing a redacted version of the tape and must use a private company’s professional services to produce the tape.

In the March 8 letter, the OIP gave the BOE until March 15, the eve of Freedom of Information Day, to comply with the law. “Any further delay by BOE in providing Mr. Geller with a copy of the audio tape cannot be reasonably justified,” OIP Director Kondo said. But the OIP has no enforcement capabilities, and Mr. Geller, whose remaining option is to take the BOE to court, has given up seeking a copy of the audio recording.

“The BOE is wrong in its refusal to release the transcripts of that meeting,” said Press Club President Peter Sur. “The delayed release of the minutes denied voters a chance to evaluate whether members seeking re-election deserved another term.

“The Board of Education is not a secret society. Its actions have a direct effect on close to 200,000 of Hawaii’s youth. Yet it acts as if accountability is a word for teachers and administrators, but not their governing body,” Sur said.

Also this year, which marks the Big Island Press Club’s 40th anniversary, the Press Club cites the Hawai‘i State Legislature again for a Lava Tube dishonorable mention. The Legislature has earned the dubious distinction each year since 1997 for continually failing to abide by the Sunshine Law which it has mandated for every other public agency in Hawai‘i.

A second dishonorable mention is reserved this year for the Hawai‘i County Council, which was found in violation of the Sunshine Law twice in 2006, each time for failing to place an item on its agenda that was subsequently discussed and voted on in violation of open public meetings requirements of the law.

Torch of Light

The Torch of Light is awarded to West Hawaii Today for its efforts in removing the veil of secrecy surrounding a case in the state Judiciary. The Kailua-Kona newspaper, owned by Stephens Media, petitioned the Hawai‘i Supreme Court to force the formerly secret lawsuit involving a prominent Big Island law firm into the public eye. The unusual nature of the secrecy involved in the case and the newspaper’s aggressive efforts to shed light on it represents outstanding service to the public’s right to know and is a worthy recipient of the Press Club’s 2007 Torch of Light, said Sur.

The Lava Tube and Torch of Light awards are announced each year on March 16, which is celebrated nationwide as Freedom of Information Day on the birthday of James Madison, the foremost champion of openness in government among the nation’s founding fathers. Madison was born in 1751.

Visit the club’s Web site: The following are the past recipients of the awards.

Torch of Light

2006 Lillian Koller, director of the state Department of Human Services

2005 Former judge and Hawai‘i County Police Commissioner Paul DeSilva

2004 University of Hawai‘i at Manoa Journalism Professor Beverly Keever

2003 U.S. Rep. Patsy Mink (posthumously)

2002 Hawai‘i County Mayor Harry Kim

2001 Hawai‘i County Clerk Al Konishi

2000 Hawai‘i Gov. Ben Cayetano

1999 Jerry Rothstein and Judith Graham

1998 Environment Hawai‘i and Common Cause

1997 Society of Professional Journalists, Hawai‘i Chapter

Lava Tube

2006 Kaua‘i County Council, Honolulu City and County Council

2005 Third Circuit District Court Judge Matthew Pyun

2004 State Land Board Chairman Peter Young

2003 State Sen. Calvin Kawamoto

2002 University of Hawai‘i Board of Regents

2001 University of Hawai‘i Board of Regents

2000 State Rep. Eric Hamakawa, Hawaii‘ County Councilman James Arakaki

1999 Hawai‘i County Council

1998 Hawai‘i Gov. Ben Cayetano

1997 Hawaii County Councilman Elroy Osorio


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.